LLC Formation Form

The disadvantages of an LLC, honestly

Every formation service sells the same three promises: protection, tax savings, legitimacy. We publish the data behind this industry, and we will tell you plainly that all three promises arrive with asterisks large enough to change decisions. This page is the asterisks.

The short answer

An LLC costs money every year whether it earns or not, saves no tax by default, does not protect you from your own negligence, and can be dissolved by the state while you are busy running it, leaving contracts and banking on shaky ground. None of that makes LLCs bad; for most operating businesses the protection is worth the rent. It makes them a subscription with terms, and the terms are state-specific.

1. The meter runs forever

A sole proprietorship costs the state nothing. An LLC is billed for existing: a formation fee, then a recurring report, statement or flat tax on a schedule that does not care whether the year was good. The expensive states are not expensive once; they are expensive annually, and the five-year totals are the honest comparison.

The most expensive states to keep an LLC alive, five-year state charges
StateFormation feeFive-year totalRecurring charge
California $70 $4,130 Statement of Information (Form LLC-12): $20, every two years
Massachusetts $500 $3,000 Annual Report: $500, annual
Delaware $110 $2,110 None, flat annual LLC tax instead: $400, annual tax (no report)
Nevada $75 $1,825 Annual List of Managers or Members + State Business License renewal: $350 ($150 list + $200 license), annual
Tennessee $300 minimum $1,800 Annual Report: $300 minimum ($50 per member, $3,000 maximum), annual
Maryland $100 $1,600 Annual Report & Personal Property Tax Return (Form 1): $300 filing fee for LLCs, annual

California is the extreme case: $4,130 over five years, of which the $800 annual franchise tax is the entire story after the $70 formation. A dormant California LLC, one with no sales and no activity, owes that $800 every year it exists, and the state collects it with penalties from people who assumed a dead business owed nothing.

2. There is no tax magic

Forming an LLC changes your tax situation by approximately nothing, by default. One member: the IRS disregards the entity and the income lands on your personal return, self-employment tax and all, exactly as it did when you were a sole proprietor. Several members: you gain a partnership return to file, which is more paperwork, not less tax. The real lever is the S corporation election, and it only starts paying once profits are high enough (a common working threshold is $40,000 to $50,000 a year) that splitting salary and distributions saves more than the added payroll and filing costs. Below that line, the election is a way to buy complexity. Anyone who tells you the LLC itself is a tax strategy is selling formations, not describing taxes.

3. The shield is thinner than the brochure

Limited liability means the business's creditors and claimants generally cannot reach your personal assets. Read the exceptions, because they describe most real small business risk. The shield does not cover your own negligence: if you personally do the work that hurts someone, you are personally in the case, LLC or not. It does not cover debts you personally guarantee, and landlords, lenders and card issuers ask for exactly that guarantee from small LLCs as a matter of routine. And it weakens or disappears when owners treat the company as a wallet: one bank account for everything, personal bills paid from business funds, no records. Courts call that commingling, and it is the standard way the veil gets pierced. For a solo operator, a proper liability insurance policy frequently matters more than the entity, because insurance responds to the negligence claims the entity does not block.

4. Let it lapse and it gets worse

The state dissolves LLCs that stop filing, and it does so quietly. Late fees first (Florida's is a flat $400), then a delinquent status any bank or counterparty can see, then administrative dissolution. Tax professionals warn about the part founders miss: a dissolved LLC is a company whose contracts, accounts and authority are all open to challenge, because the legal person on the other side of those agreements arguably was not in good standing, or did not exist, when it performed. Reinstatement usually exists and usually costs the missed years plus penalties. The disadvantage is not that the trap is deep; it is that it springs silently, on a calendar nobody gave you. Our after-you-form guide is that calendar.

5. Getting out costs money too

Closing an LLC is a filing, not a shrug: most states require articles of dissolution, final tax returns, and settling the recurring charges up to the dissolution date. Founders who simply walk away leave the meter running and meet the accumulated bill, plus penalties, the next time the state's records matter to them. Compare that with a sole proprietorship, which ends when you stop.

So when does the LLC lose?

When three facts line up: the work carries little real liability, the income is small or occasional, and the state charges real rent for the entity. That founder, in California especially, is paying $800 a year for a shield against risks a sole proprietorship plus a decent insurance policy handles as well. Flip any one of the three (clients who can sue, steady revenue, a no-upkeep state like Arizona or Wyoming) and the LLC wins the comparison for most people. The mistake is not forming or not forming. It is forming on a sales pitch instead of on your state's numbers and your business's actual risk.

Disadvantage questions

What is the biggest disadvantage of an LLC?

For most small LLCs it is not a single dramatic flaw; it is the combination of a yearly state meter that never stops and a liability shield that is narrower than advertised. The meter is knowable in advance (our index puts a number on every state). The shield covers the business's obligations, not your own negligence, and lenders routinely ask for personal guarantees that hand the risk back to you on the debts that matter most.

Does an LLC actually save taxes?

Not by existing. By default the IRS taxes a one-member LLC exactly like a sole proprietorship and a multi-member LLC like a partnership: no savings, no penalty, just pass-through. The savings lever people mean is the S corporation election, which can cut self-employment tax on part of the profit once profit is high enough to justify payroll, and it is an election you file, not a property of the LLC itself.

Can I lose the liability protection?

Yes, in documented ways: mixing personal and business money (commingling), signing personal guarantees, committing the harmful act yourself, or letting the company fall into dissolution while you keep trading. Courts disregard entities that exist only on paper. The protection is real for owners who run the company like a separate thing, because separateness is the thing being protected.

When is a sole proprietorship better than an LLC?

When the work carries little liability, income is occasional, and your state charges real money for the entity. A freelance editor in California earning a few thousand a year on the side pays $800 a year for an LLC whose shield she will likely never use; as a sole proprietor she pays nothing to the state and is taxed identically. In a no-upkeep state like Arizona the same calculation flips, because the shield costs $50 once.

State figures from official schedules, verified November 11, 2026.